Grading Guide
Not a professional grader, this is mostly used as a reference point for buying comic books and trading cards from Hidden Palace Games. There will be no number grading, the condition will be graded with a word description that best describes well... the condition!
Comics
- GM - Gem Mint: Absolutely immaculate. Nothing will be given this grade.
- M - Mint: Realistically, not going to happen either.
- NM - Near Mint/Mint: The comic appears in such a way that it doesn't have any flaws. May have some imperfections caused during the printing process.
- VF- Very Fine: Still looks really good, might be some minor things affecting its condition like corner wear due to sitting on a shelf for a long time. Might look like it has been read a few times.
- FN - Fine: Basically has a few more wear than Very Fine. This includes some normal spine wear and dented corners. The overall appearance of the comic might look something out of a newspaper stand shelf.
- VG - Very Good: Think of this as an the condition of an average or casual comic reader.
- GD - Good: It's a misnomer, comics that are graded good can have rips, stains, writing, creases, folds, etc.
- FR - Fair: Eh, okay reading copy. Might have some coupon pages cut out.
- PR - Poor: Geez, what did you do to this thing?!
Here is a chart that you can use as a quick reference of what each grade allows. Not all comics graded in a certain grade has everything bad possible happened to it. If it qualifies for any one of the lowest grade, the entire comic falls under that grade.
Grade |
Spine |
Stains |
Spine |
Cover Wear |
Corners | Rips | Paper Color |
Missing Pages |
Amateur |
Gem Mint | Tight/Flat | None | None | None | Sharp | None | Original | No | None |
Mint | Tight/Flat | None | None | None | Sharp | None | Original | No | None |
Near Mint | Tight/Flat | None | Almost none | Minor | Minor Blunt | Minor | Original | No | None |
Very Fine | Almost Flat | Minor | Minor | Minor | Minute wear | Minor | Tan/ Cream |
No | None |
Fine | Minor Rolling |
Minor |
A lot | A lot | A lot of wear | Minor | Brown/ Tan |
No | None |
Very Good | Some | Some | A lot | A lot |
Blunted |
A lot | Brown | No | Minor fix |
Good | A lot | A ton | A lot |
A ton/ |
Rounded | A lot | Brown | No | Couple |
Fair | A ton | A ton | A ton |
A ton/ |
Rounded/ |
A ton | Brown | Possibly | A lot |
Poor | GEEZ | WHAT | DID | YOU | DO | TO | THIS | THING | ?! |
Trading Cards
Trading card grading is very similar to the comic grading guide in a way, but they lack a Very Fine category. A quick reference to come at a later time.